RJ’s Pizzeria

Reviews

• George P.

  star star star star star 22 July 2026

  First the friendliest owner Frankie and the other workers. Started with a fresh antipasta and garlic knots that were full of flavor.  It was accompanied by a home tasting tomato sauce.  Then came the delicious pizza with very very fresh ingredients.  The  decor inside is warm and friendly.  Do yourself a wonderful favor, make sure you visit RJ'S PIZZERIA in Rockaway NJ

• Florence C.

  star star star star star_border 12 July 2026

  Happiness is a warm slice of pizza! Inside, this place is spacious but cozy with checkered tablecloths, brick walls, and cute pizza quotes on the wall. Just inside the entrance, a board lists their tempting daily specials. By the counter, huge slices of about 8 kinds of pie wait ready to be reheated.
  
  I ordered Mama Nata's pizza which arrived freshly made and piping hot with a thin crust and square, topped with basil, mozz, garlic, and plum tomato sauce. Though the cheese sometimes slid off my slices, it was a pretty good pie that showcased obviously fresh ingredients. On another visit, I tried a slice of plain and a slice of Spinach/Ricotta/Mozz/Garlic and both really impressed me with excellent texture and flavor. I was actually full after the first slice but didn't mind having the second. All this good pizza left me ready for a nap and super happy.
  
  NOTES/TIPS:
  **Gender-neutral restroom.
  **Plenty of parking in a private shared lot.
  **Their menu's vast with several salads, subs, wraps, and seafood/pasta/chicken entrees.
  **I brought my own water bottle twice for dining-in around lunchtime and they didn't mind at all.

• Tiffanie S.

  star star star star star 8 July 2026

  Fantastic food! I've had their catering (vodka sauce is perfect) and pizza delivered, their buffalo chicken pie is great not overly heavy like many other places and they were on time and had a great price point. I would highly recommend ordering from here.

• Lauren A.

  star star star star star_border 8 July 2026

  I stopped in for some lunch today and decided on the caprese salad and side of meatballs since I'm on a meatball kick!  This is a tiny but cute pizzeria tucked into the strip mall on Rte. 46 west near Franklin Road in Rockaway.  I thought the salad was very good although it would have (and I'm big advocate of balsamic vinegar) been just as good with a little less dressing. The cheese, basil, and mozzarella were fresh and it was very satisfying. The meatballs were also quite good and I dug the sauce. The meatballs were pretty big and had a nice flavor.  They were appropriately dense without being too full of breadcrumbs that tend to detract from the flavor value.  The salad came with three rolls and although I didn't eat them (I gave to my friend at work) they looked and felt fresh!  It took a little longer than I expected to wait for my order so next time I'll call ahead. I haven't dined in yet so I'll do an update on this review when I do. I like the little chalkboard of specials and the warmth of the simple but welcoming atmosphere and decor.

• Bill M.

  star star star star star_border 4 July 2026

  This is by far some of the Best thin crust style pizza around. They use only fresh ingredients and toppings here and you can tell in every flavorful bite. I tried the Supreme slice which I found to be 'out of this world'. The sauce is delicious and not acidic at all while the cheese has just the right amount of perfect melted goodness. The crust has a crispness to it and makes for an excellent foundation for this very delicious pizza.
  
   Service is extremely friendly and the dining area is above what you would find in any of the local pizzerias. Really cool and welcoming vibe going on with nice decor.
  
  They have a delivery service here as well which I'll definitely be checking out in the near future.